Three measures of fledgling impact

on October 30, 2017 | in Conscious

Given the variety of the fledglings, Fledge’s challenge is how to measure their collective impact.  This is a long-standing industry debate, how to measure the impact of a company in a single number, and how to aggregate that number across a portfolio of companies/organizations.

1- Pinchot Impact Index

Fledge has been using the Pinchot Impact Index since its inception, in part because it was invented by Fledge’s founder, Luni, but mostly because it works, producing a value that can be tracked over time.

More specifically, we measure three levels of impact for our portfolio of fledglings: the potential of the idea to change the world, the intended impact of the startup itself, and the amount of impact the company has actually achieved.

All measures continue their upward climb.  All the trend lines include the loss of 13 (out of 82) fledglings, who have shut down their startups.

The high potential impact is driven by two fledglings.  Evrnu, which invented a process that makes cotton recyclable.  Zirconia, which has invented a spray-on coating that will eliminate rust from steel.  These ideas each have the potential to effect tens of billions of lives and shift trillions of dollars of infrastructure spending.

Those companies will not be alone in addressing those issues, and thus the total intended impacts are lower.  The big jump in Fledge9 is from Zirconia.

Meanwhile, most of the fledglings are still quite young, and thus the total achieved impact is still quite small.  Change takes time.

To dig into the details of the P0.740, see the list of fledglings or watch the videos.

2- UN Sustainable Development Goals

Starting in 2017, Fledge started characterizing all of the fledglings using the UN Sustainable Development Goals (the “SDGs”). These are 17 goals, created by a committee at the United Nations to help explain what the world needs to bring the last few billions of people out of poverty. The taxonomy is quickly becoming the de facto standard for impact, including widespread use by impact investors.

Fledge has characterized all of the fledglings against the SDGs. The histogram of that effort is below. Each bar counts the number of fledglings that are targeting the specific goal.

None of the fledglings are working on education, hence the gap in goal #4.

Goal #8 is Decent Work and Economic Growth, and that is not surprisingly the most common given fledglings like African Chicken, Ayni, Cropital, and Jicote, which all aim to create incomes for smallholder farmers.

Goal #11 is Sustainable Cities and Communities, and that is again not surprising as the second most popular given Arqlite, Evrnu, Zijani, and Zirconia.

We’ll see over time how this histogram changes, to see if specific goals continue to dominate, or whether the values revert toward the averages seen by investorflow.org.

3- Gender Lens

Fledge selects the best companies it can find, in a process that is as gender-blind and color-blind as can be, given we interview the best applicants “face to face” over video. We do like bucking the trend in venture capital, investing in women and people of color, but neither gender nor skin color is part our selection criteria.

Nonetheless, 39% of the fledglings have a female founder or co-founder. Another 4% are companies founded by an all male team, but which specifically focus on employing and empowering women (e.g. African Chicken and Housekipp).

 
  • Shaula Massena

    That’s pretty impressive, Luni, that you’ve got something in almost every category for the UN Goals, I thought a couple goals seemed pretty un-invest-able. What are you mapping to #16 – Peace, Justice & Strong Institutions? Is Geossy your life under water? And #17 – Partnership for the Goals? Helpful food for thought.

    • It wasn’t on purpose. Most of Fledge took place before the UN settled on these 17 goals.

      #16 includes Pieta, which works with and employs prison inmates, allowing them to earn some money. In this particular Peruvian prison, that is incredibly helpful, as prisoners have to pay for the use of a bed.

      Two that cover both #16 and #17 are Africa Business Radio and Bright Reality Entertainment, both of which are more about Strong Institutions than Peace and Justice for #16, and then both help other fledglings spread their stories and thus create their impact, hence #17.

      For these and every other goal, you can visit fledglings.fledge.co, and at the top of that page click on a goal to see which fledglings are a match.